PicksInSix Review: Hamilton-Broadway in Chicago
HISTORY NEVER HAD IT SO GOOD!
PicksInSix® Gold Review | Guest Contributor | Kaitlyn Linsner
“HAMILTON” has returned to Chicago, and everyone is freaking out. Thursday’s opening night performance at The James M. Nederlander Theatre attracted a buzzing full house of people eager to experience the incredibly catchy delight that is the “HAMILTON” phenomenon. So much so that the audience cheered the moment the lights went down. Then Aaron Burr started his introduction of Alexander Hamilton, and if the backs of everyone’s bopping heads could talk, they’d have said to me: “I know every single word to this song, and I love it.”
Now, I have only seen “HAMILTON” this one time, knew maybe two songs going into opening night and most certainly was outnumbered by the repeat show goers. For years I have heard people rave about the award-winning musical’s unique storytelling of American history and great songs. For most of those years I also admittedly leaned into a contrarian disposition and assumed these people were more or less overreacting. Now, I get it.
Just about every song in “HAMILTON” is a hit. Standouts from opening night include “My Shot” because it hits like a genuine call to Chicago to join in the revolution and “RISE UP” for freedom. “Burn” because of the beautiful lyrics infused with heartbreak and bravery. “The Schuyler Sisters” because the irresistible pop melody catches like wildfire in the phrase “look around, look around” that we hear throughout the production.
Deon'te Goodman as Aaron Burr delivers a powerful performance of “Wait for It.” Throughout the production, Goodman excels in exercising restraint and then, if only for an instant, seemingly breaks free and moves with his impulses. His performance showcases Burr’s inner conflict of wanting power and prestige but being hesitant to look beyond his reservations and take risks. Other notable performances include Jared Howelton as a show-stopping Marquis de Lafayette and Thomas Jefferson, Nikisha Williams as a moving Eliza and Neil Haskell as a hilariously sneering King George.
As for storytelling techniques, the choreography by Andy Blankenbuehler, and the talented ensemble’s execution thereof, deserves equal if not greater recognition than the toe-tapping songs and creative lyrics. Much of the story relies on the ensemble’s movement. This includes the numerous styles of dance that weave us from streetscape, to bar to war with grace, power and excellent control. The ensemble also carries in props and set pieces, moves slow-motion bullets in duels and ultimately sets the stage by keeping the audience engaged and intrigued. A job well done in meeting the energy of this non-stop production but somehow also creating the necessary breathing room to take it all in.
Yet, “HAMILTON” does conjure up some ambivalence. There’s conflict between enjoying the show, respecting it for redefining theater and feeling weird about clapping along in celebration of an American nationalism that oversells mainstream history and the American dream that hard work can get you anywhere. We know that’s not true for all of us, but indulging in that narrative for the show’s quite long run-time does open the door to connecting with something better, which is the show’s examination of personal experiences that cannot be separated from larger political structures. Much of “HAMILTON’s” impact is in exploring what it means to be enough, finding community, the limitations of intellectualizing emotions and the power of grief and deep vulnerability. There’s revolution to be had in our collective human experience, and “HAMILTON” is the wildly entertaining reminder to lean into the movement and not throw away your shot.
GUEST CONTRIBUTOR | KAITLYN LINSNER is a Chicago-based attorney practicing construction and surety law.
PHOTO|Joan Marcus
Official Show Website
Tickets
Ham4Ham Lottery
Cast
For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago
PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC