PicksInSix Review: A Midsummer Night's Dream - Chicago Shakespeare Theater
“That yet we sleep, we dream.”
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy
Among all of Shakespeare’s plays, “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” is arguably the most-produced comedy and vies with “Hamlet,” “Romeo and Juliet,” and that Scottish play for the top spot in the canon. So it is safe to say that if you are a longtime fan of Shakespeare, you have probably seen several productions of “Midsummer,” as recently as 2019 at Shakes, or the 1999 film with Stanley Tucci as Puck and Kevin Kline as Bottom among its’ all-star cast.
No matter how you feel about the whimsical forest where the jealous King Oberon raises havoc with the heart of his lovely Queen Titania or just how Bottom’s excessive ego is magnified when magically transformed to an ass, chances are you will have never seen a production quite like the one that is currently playing in repertory on Navy Pier with “The Winter’s Tale.” Director Edward Hall has delivered a timeless, fast-paced, comic gem that will be just the tonic to warm the frosty air off Lake Michigan and the perfect complement for Hall’s new repertory company.
When I first saw the fine production of the “The Winter’s Tale,” I imagined for a moment how Michael Pavelka’s scenic design would be adapted for this show. The Jentes Family Courtyard Theater’s thrust stage shimmers as a stylized performance backdrop. But the real artistry of the design is realized in “Midsummer” with cleverly disguised entry points, elaborate use of silks, pillows and glitter. These are two distinctly different visions, anchored by one very simple, yet effective, device that is revealed at the top of each show. Very clever indeed.
The stellar accomplishment here is in Hall’s casting of an extremely talented repertory company who glide through this show with so much enthusiasm, never yielding to the theatricality of it all, in favor of clear, understandable and highly entertaining character treatments that frankly make aspects of the play come alive in a way that I have never seen before.
At the center of this shimmering production is the inspired and physically demanding performance of Patty Roache as Robin Goodfellow. Whether suspended twenty feet in the air or ascending from the depths of the stage, Roache reimagines Puck as kinetic energy, circling and serving Sean Fortunato’s delightful take on King Oberon to elevate the text in a way that feels fresh and exciting. Fortunato with Jessica Dean Turner as Titania, Queen of the Fairies, have a commanding presence on the vast stage and over the fairy minions who serve them. The young lovers—Hermia (Felicia Oduh), Demetrius (Esteban Ortiz-Villacorta), Lysander (Dan Haller) and Helena (Grace Steckler)—are perfectly matched. Steckler, whose charming comic abilities are showcased here, handles the absurdity of her suitors affections with childlike wonder. Hall has crisply choreographed the action between Demetrius and Lysander with urgency and humor that often pushes the text to new boundaries. Oduh’s Hermia goes toe to toe with Steckler’s Helena in all the best ways.
All comic boundaries are evaporated for the hilarious Mechanicals—Peter Quince (Erik Hellman), Nick Bottom (Chiké Johnson), Frances Flute (Kieran McCabe), Robin Starveling (Issy Van Randwyck), Tom Snout (Ronald L. Conner) and Snug (Demetrios Troy)—artisans of the play within the play—with Wall, Lion and the rest—following the wedding of Theseus (Fortunato) and Hippolyta (Dean Turner). Much more than a gentle dive into low comedy, which is becoming a prominent theme in Hall’s interpretations, and it worked well for me, particularly a brief moment of modern improvisation for Hellman that had me and everyone else howling. A magical story, richly told at Shakes.
PHOTO | Kyle Flubacker
Chicago Shakespeare Theater
presents
A Midsummer Night’s Dream
Jentes Family Courtyard Theater
Navy Pier
through January 3, 2027
In repertory with
The Winter’s Tale
(through December 12)
WEBSITE
For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago
PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC