PicksInSix Review: The Great Gatsby: A New Musical - Broadway in Chicago

“BORNE BACK CEASELESSLY INTO THE PAST”
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

The splashy opulence of the 1920s Jazz Age comes to life in the national touring production of "The Great Gatsby: A New Musical," which opened at Broadway in Chicago's Cadillac Palace Theatre on Wednesday night. F. Scott Fitzgerald's 1925 novel—considered by many one of the finest works of the 20th century—explores wealth, power, privilege and intrigue. The stage adaptation features a book by Kait Kerrigan with music by Jason Howland and lyrics by Nathan Tysen and is directed by Marc Bruni with choreography by Dominique Kelly.

Jake Davis Smith and Senzel Ahmady star as the ill-fated lovers Jay Gatsby and Daisy Buchanan, reunited through Daisy's cousin Nick Carraway, played by Joshua Grosso. Carraway's romance with Daisy's best friend, amateur golfer Jordan Baker (Leanne Robinson), draws him into Gatsby's extravagant world. There he uncovers that Daisy's domineering husband Tom (Will Banner) is having an affair with Myrtle Wilson (Lila Coogan), the socially ambitious wife of George Wilson (Tally Sessions)—a well-meaning mechanic entangled in a bootlegging operation run by the nefarious Meyer Wolfsheim (Edward Staudenmayer).

By necessity, the musical reimagines Carraway as less of a narrator than in Fitzgerald's novel, where his voice serves as the story's binding, poetic force. Even so, Kerrigan's book successfully frames the story's broader themes, though some of the darker character details—fully exposed when the tide turns on Gatsby—are condensed along the way.

That depth emerges through the lush Howland-Tysen score. Highlights include Smith's soaring ballad "For Her," the duet "My Green Light" with Ahmady, and "Past Is Catching Up With Me." Robinson shines alongside Grosso, Staudenmayer and the company in the swinging "New Money" and with Grosso in "Better Hold Tight." Ahmady's "For Better or Worse," Coogan's "Second-Hand Suit," "God Sees Everything," and Grosso's "The Met" also stand out. Ensemble numbers "Roaring On" and "Shady" are stellar and Joann Gilliam's Gilda Gray alongside the electric performance of The Sugars (Anna Gassett, Josiah Hicks, Tyler Johnson-Campion and Macy McKown) steal the show with "La Dee Dah With You."

The production unfolds on Paul Tate DePoo III's magnificent set, whose elegant panels and scenic elements frame vivid projections—from the shimmering shoreline and Daisy's green dock light to Gatsby's grand estate, Carraway's Long Island cottage, the Sugar Hill apartment, the Plaza Hotel suite and George's garage in the Valley of Ashes, loomed over by Doctor T. J. Eckleburg's billboard eyes. Two cars—Tom's modest blue coupe and Gatsby's gleaming yellow roadster—make a striking and memorable impression. Linda Cho's exquisite costumes and Cory Pattak's lighting design complete a stunning visual tapestry.

Ultimately, "The Great Gatsby: A New Musical" is an American tragedy of indulgence and deception—a portrait of the privileged few who sacrifice integrity for self-preservation. It is a reflection that feels urgent for this moment in time, and a powerful reminder of the enduring significance of Fitzgerald's work and the flickering green light of hope for the future.

PHOTO|Evan Zimmerman for MurphyMade

Broadway in Chicago
presents
The Great Gatsby
A New Musical
Cadillac Palace Theater
through May 3, 2026

WEBSITE

TICKETS

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: Amélie - "A Feeling of Absolute Harmony" - Kokandy Productions

Amélie - "A Feeling of Absolute Harmony"
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

The Chicago premiere of “Amélie: The Musical,” now playing in an exquisite Kokandy production at Chopin Theatre that opened Saturday in the intimate Downstairs Studio, is based on the 2001 award-winning French film written by Jean-Pierre Jenet and Guillaume Laurent. It was adapted for the stage—book by Craig Lucas, music by Dan Meese and lyrics by Meese and Nathan Tysen— and debuted in 2015 at the Berkeley Repertory Theater followed by a brief Broadway run in 2017, a UK tour in 2019 moving to the West End for a summer 2021 run.

The Kokandy production is directed and choreographed by Artistic Director Derek Van Barham with music direction by T. J. Anderson and Anna Wegener. The already lush and whimsical score has been enhanced with additional instrumentation that, in the talented and capable hands of twelve superb actors/singers/musicians, create a glorious experience of sight, sound and song. “Amélie” fits perfectly in the Chopin space and has all the makings of a colossal hit for Kokandy.

Amélie Poulain is a dreamer who overcomes early childhood isolation, and unimaginable loss, using all she has learned for good, to approach the world with wonder and spreading playful joy to everyone around her. Along the way, she builds confidence and develops a circle of friends and mentors who help her gain her own independence, ultimately, revealing the elusive love and affection she has yearned for all her life.

Aurora Penepacker is simply mesmerizing as Amélie, displaying a captivating stage presence that is only surpassed by her stunning vocal abilities. Penepacker, whose star shone brightly last season in Writers “Great Comet,” delivers a multi-layered performance, bursting with enthusiasm and beguiling charm, that is delightful to watch. True to the original story, Penepacker’s Amélie leads us through the mystery of a 40 year-old tin treasure box; the forging of romantic relationships at the café where she works; healing the broken heart of a co-worker; and, bringing peace and solitude to her grieving father.

All the while, the evolving relationship with Nino Quincampoix (Joe Giovannetti, in top form), the object Amélie’s desire, becomes her passionate focus. It is not just how Amélie attracts Nino, the shy and earnest collector of discarded subway photo booth images, but the interconnecting paths of all of the unique characters who serve as narrators to move the story along. Even though this feels very much like a collaborative ensemble experience throughout, Amélie’s parents Amandine (Rachel Carreras) and Raphael (Kelan M. Smith, who also covers Bretodeau), Sonia Goldberg’s Gina (“Window Seat”) and Jon Patrick Penick (Collignon/Julien Dufayel) and the company’s Act I closer “Goodbye, Amélie” leave memorable impressions.

The fine work of dialect coach Carrie Hardin is evident. The vast instrumentation—I lost count at twelve—and the quality of the musical performances is a credit to every member of the company—backed up by Kara Olander and Anna Wegener—who contribute to the exquisite harmonies. “Amélie: The Musical” has it all from an outstanding, energetic cast to an accomplished technical team—sound design by Matt Reich, mixed and engineered by Lynsy Folckomer and Mackenzie Hahn, set and lights by G “Max” Maxin IV and costumes by Rachel Sypniewski—all combining for a rich and robust vocal and instrumentation mix that is in a word: Magnifique!  

PHOTO|Michael Brosilow

Kokandy Productions
presents
Amélie
Chopin Theatre
Downstairs Studio
1543 W. Division Street
through September 28, 2025

WEBSITE

PROGRAM

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: PARADISE SQUARE

View fullsize

JOAQUINA KALUKANGO—A NIGHT TO REMEMBER!

The fiercely defiant performance of Joaquina Kalukango in the role of Nelly O’Brien electrifies the ambitious new Garth H. Drabinsky produced musical “Paradise Square” directed by Moisés Kaufman that opened its pre-Broadway run on Wednesday at Chicago’s James M. Nederlander Theatre. Throttling up in the face of adversity through the clash of cultures story during the Civil War, Kalukango stunned the opening night audience with the epic and emotional Act II anthem “Let It Burn” that resonates with such strength as to cross generational lines and echo the issues of our time. It is a powerful coda to a complex musical about social inequality and unrest whose score splendidly weaves together 19th century Irish immigrant and African American dance styles.  

Up front, it is important to note that after nearly three years of civil war, President Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation on September 22, 1862, however, the Proclamation only applied to specified rebellious states and regions. When it was enacted on January 1, 1863, the Proclamation had already served as much to define the war as a fight for freedom from slavery as it did to further polarize the unsettling and growing hostility between the surging immigrant communities in the North and those freeborn Black Americans and escaped slaves seeking a safe haven.

The Five Points district in New York City was a melting pot for freeborn Black Americans and Irish immigrant populations whose work and intermixed family lives found common ground in the shared desperation of poverty. Fueled by white upper class discrimination that perpetuated their containment to the area, the cultures were actually allowed to coexist and, in many cases, prosper in the midst of the deplorable conditions. However, what could be a new order was not. As casualties from the long and brutal war continued to mount, attitudes sharply eroded. In April 1863, when Congress enacted a draft that exempted those who could pay their way out of service or enlist a substitute in their place, the inequities were laid bare. The draft order also unjustly disqualified the Black population in New York from serving, despite many other regiments already in place, leading to descension, mistrust, and, ultimately, violence in the form of the death and destruction during the July 1863 New York Draft Riots.

It is at this historical tipping point that the show begins with a flashback to Five Points in late 1862, with the escalating war as a dramatic background. Nelly (Kalukango) is the Black owner of Paradise Square, a brothel that welcomes everyone to mix and celebrate. With her white husband, Will O’Brien (Matt Bogart), her brother Reverend Samuel Jacob Lewis (Nathaniel Stampley) and his wife Annie Lewis (Chilina Kennedy), the titular opening number exudes the ethnic stamp of the neighborhood as a welcoming, inclusive and safe place.  We quickly meet Annie’s nephew, Owen Duignan (A.J.Shivley), an Irish immigrant and Washington Henry (Sidney DuPont), an escaped slave who are given shelter by Nelly and her husband while Milton Moore a/k/a Stephen Foster (Jacob Fishel) is offered a job as a piano player.

There are several storylines to unpack along the way within the book written by Christina Anderson, Marcus Gardley, Craig Lucas and Larry Kirwan, who is also credited with conceiving the work. Nelly and Annie are under scrutiny by the uptown boss Frederic Tiggins (John Dossett) that results in fines and threats of closure. When “Lucky” Mike Quinlan (Kevon Dennis) returns from the war disabled and bitter about his personal situation and the loss of jobs available for Irish dockworkers, he leads a public protest against the draft decree that will further diminish the rights of Irish immigrants who are at the top of the draft list. Fearing that he will be drafted to fight for a cause he does not believe in, Owen competes for a $300 prize—a years pay at the time—that will buy his exemption from service, while Washington, desperate to be reunited with his wife Angelina Baker (Gabrielle McClinton), walks a tight rope between the flight to freedom and prosecution for past actions.

The company of over fifty actors and musicians perform twenty musical numbers—music by Jason Howland with lyrics by Nathan Tysen and Masi Asare—on a massive, multi-level Allen Moyer designed urban set that evokes a gritty, mid-19th century landscape and incorporates gorgeous Toni-Leslie James costumes. The orchestral arrangements would benefit greatly with the addition of a box accordion for a larger and more varied interpretation in the Irish step-dancing numbers enhancing the strong fusion of all of the dance numbers. Bill T. Jones choreography is exhilarating. The music of Stephen Foster is uniquely interpreted by Kirwan including “Oh Susanna” all superbly performed by the ensemble. Notable highlights include Stampley and DuPont’s “I’d Be A Soldier”, Kalukango and Kennedy’s touching ballad “Someone to Love” and “Ring, Ring the Banjo”—a perfect spot for a banjo solo. The wide-ranging elements of the book tend to minimize Nelly’s compelling story. In the shadow of a devastating war, there is more than enough material to increase the dramatic tension, but that hardly matters to the overall enjoyment of the searing final moments of Kalukango’s exhilarating performance that will make anyone’s visit to “Paradise Square” a night to remember.  

PHOTO|Kevin Berne

BROADWAY IN CHICAGO
presents
PARADISE SQUARE
James M. Nederlander Theatre
24 West Randolph
through December 5, 2021

TICKETS

SHOW WEBSITE

PARADISE SQUARE begins previews February 22, 2022 at Broadway’s Barrymore Theatre, 243 West 47th Street, where it opens March 20, 2022. TICKETS

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC