PicksInSix Review: Catch as Catch Can - Steppenwolf Theatre Company

Diabolically Clever “Catch” Turns On Dime
PicksInSix® Review | Guest Contributor | Ronald Keaton

What a challenging piece of theatre this is. Three actors play six different characters in Mia Chung's diabolically clever play “Catch as Catch Can,” now playing at Steppenwolf's Downstairs Theatre through July 12. In director Amy Morton’s eloquent staging, the solid trio of actors play two characters each. They offer an adult child and a parent—a son to the mother or a daughter to the father. We jump genders and ages, even while standing alone.

There are two families, close friends and all, the Phelans and the Lavecchias. They welcome home a kind of prodigal son, setting off an evolving crisis that reshapes their lives and, as we discover, the play itself. In Mia Chung’s play, three actors perform across race, gender, and generation—a family drama that doubles as a theatrical tour-de-force. It's a fascinating stew of six disparate personalities who are a lot of fun to observe—until they cease to be.

A startling shift kicks into gear midway into this trip through a history of the families, when Tim shares an unnerving revelation about his fiancée Mingjin with Daniela that changes everything. It shades the play toward a much more sobering, sad realization. The family dynamics here intertwine and are as changeable as the weather. But as we discover the secret, we also witness this man's hellbent personal self-destruction and mental illness. It's uncomfortable to observe and hard to follow. The mental, emotional breakdown throws the entire story askew, and we are asked to live now in a different kind of reality.

What seems at first like a family comedy takes a sharp turn that rips apart not only the person who suffers from it, but the fabric of the play itself.  The sudden, emotional separation from the comedic turns is damned scary and often disorienting. Confusion does indeed reign, as the work of communicating a sense of chaos only makes blurry the lines of the dual identities the actors are asked to do.  And that double-casting, as utilized here, aspires to be more than a gimmick. It is, in fact, central to what the show wants to share about what people do or do not get from family.

When all is said and done, we wonder why. This is indeed challenging material that few theatres in existence would try so fully. There are three of the best onstage, too—Gary Cole, Tim Hopper and Audrey Francis. The stagecraft, the acting, the technical aspects, all of these are up to Steppenwolf's expected brilliance. Director Morton is a veritable genius in helping her actors delineate character, often in the same body playing two different people.

But the play itself—and from one of our great, innovative playwrights in the theatre—trips over such cleverness and innovation. “Catch as Catch Can” is well worth seeing. But what one takes from it might be as strange and difficult as the situation itself. Then again, maybe that's the point. Humanity is, after all, often a chaotic condition, which would then make such creativity here worthwhile.

GUEST CONTRIBUTOR | RONALD KEATON received an Equity Jeff Award for the performance of his one-man show CHURCHILL. www.solochicagotheatre.com.  Coming soon, his new solo play about Ben Franklin, THE FIRST EMBASSY.

PHOTO|Michael Brosilow

Steppenwolf Theatre Company
presents
Catch as Catch Can
Downstairs Theater
1650 N. Halsted St.
through July 12

WEBSITE

TICKETS

PROGRAM

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: Fool for Love - Steppenwolf Theatre Company

Searing ‘Fool for Love’ At Steppenwolf
PicksInSix Review | Guest Contributor Ronald Keaton

The great Sam Shepard play “Fool for Love,” now playing at Steppenwolf Theatre through March 23, was written in the middle of a quality string of highly volatile, verbally explosive plays about family that he penned in an eight-year period between 1977 and 1985. including “Buried Child” (which won Mr. Shepard his Pulitzer Prize in 1979) and “True West”(which had a legendary Steppenwolf production). In 1984, “Fool for Love” was itself nominated for a Pulitzer Prize and purportedly was written after the playwright’s divorce from his first wife, resulting in a outpouring of personal, emotional fallout that produced this searing piece of theatre.

Make no mistake—the play itself is the star.  May and Eddie are star-crossed lovers who meet yet again in a motel out in the Mojave Desert. There is a taut, difficult dynamic between these two that produces a dreaded secret to face. Sitting outside the motel is the otherworldly spirit of The Old Man, whose influence on this relationship is both relentless and disturbing, because of that secret that no one wishes to discuss.

May (played by Caroline Neff, at once both feisty and vulnerable) has been abandoned by Eddie (Nick Gehlfuss as the brawling rodeo star) one too many times. She wants nothing to do with him and repeatedly demands that he leave.  Yet when he actually threatens to leave, May is suddenly a child-like being, afraid of being left alone. The dichotomy here produces a quite visceral and intense piece of theatre narrative. Eddie feels the need to dominate the proceedings, and even the history between them, as if they would tell two different stories. May bucks right back, reminding him of his endless disloyalty. And the story of their shared lives is unique and shocking.

So May has a date that was planned before Eddie’s arrival. Enter Martin (Cliff Chamberlain, who offers fine comic relief as a bumbling suitor) into the fray. Talk about a fish out of water. Martin is so innocent and shy that his initial exchange with Eddie turns into a kind of staggering fascination as to what kind of man this rodeo guy really is. And Martin is totally drawn into the tale that Eddie tells about his youth, meeting May and discovering a guise of love that he’d never witnessed, let alone felt before. By now, May has come out of the bathroom, having listened through the door at all of Eddie’s story and wanting to immediately correct him on the facts of the matter.

Finally, the Old Man (the appropriately craggy Tim Hopper in an almost Big Daddy guise), whose stance throughout has been to inject his own brutal viewpoint onto the story, finally awakens his ghostly aura, manifesting at last into a genuine voice to Eddie, almost begging him to “tell the truth and represent me.” If a viewer has never seen this play, this writer will spare you the tawdry details of what happens at the end. Suffice it to say that at the time of its writing, “Fool for Love” was a staggering example of “the sins of the father” that Mr. Shepard so comfortably shares here.

Coming from the recent Broadway debut of the stage version of John LeCarre’s novel “The Spy Who Came In From The Cold” is the English director Jeremy Herrin. Todd Rosenthal produces a dependable set design in a seedy motel, complete with neon sign above. Heather Gilbert shows a lighting design with “on-fire” effects shooting into the room from outside visitors. Mikhail Fiksel offers shots and explosions onto Eddie’s truck from those same visitors, as well as the occasional George Strait melody in his sound design.  It’s a short play at roughly 65 minutes or so, but one will find that hour full of passion and a fury all its own.

GUEST CONTRIBUTOR | RONALD KEATON received an Equity Jeff Award for the performance of his one-man show CHURCHILL. www.solochicagotheatre.com  Coming soon, his new solo play “Echo Holler.” www.echoholler.com

PHOTO | Michael Brosilow

Steppenwolf Theatre Company
presents
Fool for Love
1650 N. Halsted St.
(312) 335-1650
through March 23, 2025

WEBSITE

TICKETS

PROGRAM

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC