PicksInSix Review: The Irish... and How They Got That Way - Porchlight Music Theatre

“We Are The Dreamers Of Dreams.”
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

There is a bit of the blarney in all of us, whether we celebrate Irish traditions once a year or every day. The Porchlight Music Theatre production of Frank McCourt’s rousing play “The Irish... and How They Got That Way” that opened Friday at the Ruth Page Center for the Arts toasts that indominable spirit in story and song, spanning the bitter dispute between Irish settlers and England, the devastating potato famine and mass emigration of the mid-19th century to the remarkably broad influence of Irish culture in every facet of our American way of life from labor and politics to music, literature and fine arts.

From the moving opening solo of “Butterfly” by Elleon Dobias (the Violinist) and citing Arthur O'Shaughnessy's 1873 "Ode" "We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams" to the resolute U2 anthem “I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For,” director David Girolmo and four of Chicago’s finest actor/singers take us through a heart-warming homage to the resilience of Irish heritage in America. McCourt’s spirited piece, with original music arrangements by Rusty Magee, serves up an entirely fresh perspective, working simultaneously as a historical retrospective with lively and poignant storytelling and a lyrical musical song and dance fest that encourages the audience to join in.

The seasoned ensemble—Michael Mahler, Leah Morrow, Emily Goldberg and Luke Nowakoski—each deliver highly-charged, often hilariously comic, solo performances and ensemble numbers under Girolomo’s superbly-paced direction with fine work by music director David Fiorello. Fiorello, the Pianist, also performs a touching rendition of “Danny Boy” and provided additional musical arrangements. Violinist Dobias adds percussion and Mahler plays guitar during the show that features well over thirty songs in all.

The storyline, supported by the beautifully performed score—an arc that reminds us of the painful challenges and staggering consequences of all immigrants to America—is a sweeping historical panorama. The players remain on stage throughout with minimal costume embellishments, pivoting effortlessly as the narrative elements shift between them allowing a charming variety of individual characters to emerge along the way.

Girolomo has a long history with the show dating back to the Chicago debut production over three decades ago. With staging designed by Tianxuam Chen—a rustic, wooden crossover upstage framed by tall ship sails and a modestly-sized video panel with imaging and lighting by G. Max Maxim IV—allows the show to unfold with ease, celebrating the people and accomplishments through the years with honest, heartfelt references to notables from the past to present day.

It’s the unique spirit of the piece that makes Porchlight’s “The Irish” a musical feast that is sure to be an audience favorite in the weeks leading up to St. Patrick’s Day in Chicago. It’s a terrific night out and a vivid reminder that we all have an origin story connected in infinite ways through our ability to overcome hardships, foster respect for each other, and live our best lives with dignity and purpose—a message that applies to every one of us during the times in which we live.

PHOTO | Anthony Robert La Penna

Porchlight Music Theatre
presents
The Irish… and How They Got That Way
Ruth Page Center for the Arts
1016 N. Dearborn Street
through March 15, 2026

TICKETS

WEBSITE

PROGRAM

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: The Dance of Death - Steppenwolf Theatre Company

Steppenwolf Steps Boldly Into Strindberg’s ‘Dance’
PicksInSix® Review | Guest Contributor | Ronald Keaton

Now playing at Steppenwolf through March 22, the Swedish playwright August Strindberg's taut, visceral play “The Dance of Death” is a story of a power struggle within a long marriage, the emotional abuse it produces, and the influence of societal laws on personal relationships. And in a remarkable adaptation by the great Irishman Conor McPherson, it becomes more than just a dark comedy full of societal turmoil as molded from the grand hands of a Steppenwolf stalwart, director Yasen Peyankov.

There are three characters in this play, all filled with their angst. The story is about a married couple storming quite haphazardly toward their 25th wedding anniversary. They hate each other in brutal and ferocious ways. The husband, who is called Captain, is an artilleryman who rules his home with a military fervor of iron. His wife, Alice, is a former actress. They live in isolation on an island— it doesn't matter where it is. Their two children don't live with them, as their parents have methodically turned them against the other parent. The Captain is having heart problems and may not have long to live. Alice sometimes plays the piano as her husband dances a kind of bizarre sword pattern. As he dances, she hopes it might kill him, and he threatens to cut her out of his will. Enter Kurt, a distant cousin to Alice, and the man who introduced the couple to each other. Kurt has his own history about him. He's divorced and the courts have banned him from contact with his own children. Kurt has come to the island to, as he says, "find peace"... read: got religion. Both Captain and Alice have their own versions of Kurt's role in their beginnings. All three are doggedly distrusting of life and of each other.

Jeff Perry offers one of the most eccentric, unique comic performances imaginable as the dominating Captain. It's complex and challenging, almost Pythonesque. In these experienced hands, Captain is at once a full-on monster of a marriage partner, only to be self-denigrating and capricious in his authoritarian revealing of his own inferiority. With an ever-present mustache and brass-buttoned coat, Mr. Perry grabs us from his first entrance with a wild walk and interpretation that forces us to hold on in its creative joy. Thank you, costume designer Ana Kuzmanic.

Kathryn Erbe as Alice, the long-suffering yet dish-it-back wife, is also elegantly inflated in her opinion of herself. Alice has funneled her theatrical ways into her married life. So many of her responses, while just as withering, take on a sniper's mount. Ms. Erbe is simply marvelous in her expertise here. The entire relationship moves almost violently toward an obvious, modern comparison—Edward Albee and his George and Martha. Both couples can only express their hate and anger in such ways that somehow the codependency evolves into a strange kind of love. And unlike Martha, who lets it all go all the time, this Alice takes her shots carefully without much raising of the voice.

Alice and Kurt show a sexualized regard for each other, one that takes a bit of a side trip into aggressive behavior. Kurt (Cliff Chamberlain as a man seemingly unaware of his own weaknesses in character) is, at first, so innocent and righteous, dazzled by the emotional battle in front of him. Then he lets his guard down, expresses his long-dormant attraction to Alice, and realizes the predicament into which he has arrived. It all, of course, drives him out the door with the proclamation "You both deserve this hell you've created!" Mr. Chamberlain is both charming and powerful.

The monolithic castle the couple lives in was born from the fertile imagination of scenic designer Collette Pollard. Lee Fiskness creates a lighting design of wide variety, with subtle tones in the family battleground area combined with sharp, revealing shafts of light and shading. Ultimately, one might rightfully ask what makes such desecration of the human spirit so funny. In the knowing minds of both Mr. Strindberg and Mr. McPherson, we are held in total thrall by an excellent cast and crew that step so boldly toward such storytelling.

GUEST CONTRIBUTOR | RONALD KEATON received an Equity Jeff Award for the performance of his one-man show CHURCHILL. www.solochicagotheatre.org.  Coming soon, his new solo play about Ben Franklin, THE FIRST EMBASSY.

PHOTO|

Steppenwolf Theatre Company
presents
The Dance of Death
Downstairs Theater
1650 North Halsted Street
through March 22, 2026

WEBSITE

PROGRAM

STUDY GUIDE

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: Salome - Lyric Opera of Chicago

“A Dark and Enthralling Operatic Experience”
PicksInSix® Review | Guest Contributor | Kaitlyn Linsner

Richard Strauss’s “Salome” premiered in Chicago in 1910 and caused such uproar that after two performances, the opera was moved to Milwaukee. Soprano Mary Garden starred in the title role with a portrayal of the unsettling teenage princess that the president of the Chicago Law and Order League called “disgusting” in a letter to the Chief of Police. What a scandalous and iconic debut.

Now, after a twenty-year absence, “Salome” returns to the Lyric Opera of Chicago as provocative as ever. This North American premiere of Sir David McVicar’s production, directed by Julia Burbach, examines greed, lust, delusion, and obsession against a brutalist, raw concrete backdrop in 1930s fascist Italy. This production also marks my very first experience at the opera. What a thrilling and delightfully gory introduction to the art form.

Based on Oscar Wilde’s one-act play, “Salome” beautifully captures a dark world of limitless power and entitlement. Salome (Jennifer Holloway) leaves a lavish dinner party to escape the lustful and predatory gaze of her stepfather Herod (Alex Boyer). She then discovers the mesmerizing voice of Jochanaan (Nicholas Brownlee) imprisoned below the basement and demands to see him. Salome convinces Narraboth (Ryan Capozzo), a man utterly infatuated with her, to release the prophet momentarily so she can promptly appease her fascinations. Feelings escalate for Salome, and she quickly descends into a ravenous obsession with Jochanaan which drives an unrelenting pursuit of his adoration and affection. Jochanaan, however, denies every single one of her advances. He remains steadfast in his repulsion, curses Salome, curses her mother, and then returns to the prison.

Following this haunting display, and brilliant vocal performance, of Salome’s desperation and the prophet’s rejection, Herod, Salome’s mother Herodias (Tanja Ariane Baumgartner) and the dinner guests enter the basement for more madness. Jochanaan continues his misogynistic railing against Herodias from the cistern. Dinner guests argue over theology. The powerful orchestra under Tomáš Netopil delivers drama and extravagance. Herod remains fixated on Salome and promises her anything she wants if she dances for him. Despite her mother’s protests, Salome accepts the offer and the infamous “Dance of the Seven Veils” begins. In this staging, Salome performs the dance for her stepfather with hesitation. She struggles with the power she yields over Herod, and the brooding set design (Es Devlin and revival lighting design by Chris Maravich) creates an undertone of distress, not eroticism. As they move through the changing environments, we too experience her inner turmoil, and for those who chose not to read the synopsis beforehand like myself, we wonder which of Salome’s desires pushes her to undergo such deep and twisted pain.

Is it love? Surely love cannot be what drives Salome to demand the prophet’s head on a silver platter in exchange for her dance. But what is love in a palace of egomania? To have? To hold? Herod offers Salome jewels, royalty, land, anything else, and yet, all Salome wants is the head of a man who denied her—the “scarlet viper” tongue that “spat its venom” upon her. She gets his head, of course, delivered by a naked executioner no less, and then begins a mesmerizing near 17-minute monologue completely detached from reality. Covered in his blood, she lays with Jochanaan’s head, toggling between boasting about how she can kiss him now and lamenting over how he still will not return her gaze. Holloway’s commanding, all-consuming performance and the shocking conclusion left me stunned in the best way.

Between the dark story, history, powerful vocalists, cold and jarring staging, and dramatic score, I have not seen anything quite like “Salome.” The production works well as an introduction to opera while also showcasing the high-level vocal artistry, raw emotion, beautiful music, and an epic set design that I am told veteran opera-goers love. I feel compelled to express my gratitude to the Lyric, the production team, and the company for this memorable experience. Brava! Bravo! Well done!

GUEST CONTRIBUTOR | KAITLYN LINSNER serves as an Assistant Attorney General in the Public Utilities Bureau of the Office of the Illinois Attorney General.

PHOTO CREDIT
Kyle Flubacker
Andrew Cioffi

Lyric Opera of Chicago
presents
Salome
20 North Wacker Drive
through February 14, 2026

TICKETS

WEBSITE

PROGRAM BOOK

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: Stereophonic - Broadway in Chicago

Rumour Has It: The Radio Edit
PicksInSix® Review | Guest Contributor | Sarah Frances Fiorello

In 2024, “Stereophonic” made history garnering a whopping 13 Tony Award nominations, the most ever received by a play. It went on to win five Tony Awards, as well as a smattering of Drama League Awards, Outer Critics Circle Awards. The prior year, it brought home an impressive seven Drama Desk Awards from its off-Broadway production at Playwrights Horizons. A shortened version of the play, dubbed as “The Radio Edit” by writer David Adjmi, is embarking on its First National Tour, opening Wednesday and playing at Broadway In Chicago’s CIBC Theatre through February 8.

The play begins nearly mid-sentence, dropping us in without a running start to the durational drama of seven characters (eight if you count the recreational drugs)—five bandmates and two sound engineers—who bear a striking and legally controversial resemblance to “Fleetwood Mac,” the subject of a now-settled lawsuit over the story loosely tracing the recording of “Rumours,” the legendary and notorious album. “Stereophonic” spans one year in four acts, over roughly 2 hours and 50 minutes of stage time, cut from its Broadway run time of 3 hours and 10 minutes. We watch this group of deeply talented and deeply troubled musicians struggle with their rising fame, inner demons, and what it means to gain the world while simultaneously losing the most important things in it: all while making a live, one-of-a-kind album right before our eyes.

There’s much to appreciate about this production, not the least of which is a truly talented group of multi-hyphenate artists who, for nearly three hours, deliver faithfully to their characters, the story, and, well, a delightfully nostalgic ‘70s vibe. Christopher Mowod as the lovable drunk-sober-drunk again Reg is charming and heartbreaking, all wrapped up in one.  Jack Barrett as Grover shows us what it’s like to love something so much, you’d go to hell and back for it, and how to perfectly time the swivel of a chair to get a laugh from an 1,800-seat theatre. Denver Milord as Peter gives us a front row seat on his genius-narcissist rollercoaster, while Claire Dejean as Diana, his lover and bandmate, suffers underfoot. And did I mention? They do all this while recording a live, one-of-a-kind album, right before our very eyes.

This play takes its time. It settles into long pauses and relishes in the pedestrian and mundane dialogue you very well might hear sitting around with a group of friends or artists who don’t realize they are on stage and responsible for entertaining you. It moves at a pace that mimics the painstaking and methodical slowness of making something excellent. It details the granularity of perfection and the all-too-common breakdown that accompanies it. I minded none of these things. In a time when entertainment moves at frames per second as if cooked in a microwave oven, I was grateful to slow all the way down to sit with these characters on a cold January evening in Chicago.

That said, I was left wanting more. Having not seen the Broadway production, the version that made a big splash and churned out tons of happy patrons, I can’t say for sure what is lacking here or what changed. Perhaps it has lost layers of character development when trimming down to “The Radio Edit” version—those small twists and turns that are revelatory, allowing us to see ourselves in the characters and have compassion for them. The plot—while intentionally left at a low hum—felt muddied. Some points were under-developed, like the relationship between Holly and Reg, and others overly-stressed, like Peter’s run amok, self-destructive journey. Maybe something intimate is foregone in moving to a theatre house nearly double the size of the Golden Theatre, where it received such a warm Broadway reception. Maybe something is lost in moving the show, period. Some spaces are sacred and carry a bit of magic. Just like the recording studios legendary musicians have been flocking to for decades.

Still: go see “Stereophonic.”  I will always advocate that a night at the theatre is a night well spent and that theatre doesn’t need to be great or perfect to be moving or important. Anything that reveals our shared humanity, especially right now, is worthy of our time. Go enjoy some classic rock music, composed by Arcade Fire’s Will Butler, performed in a setting that—in the context of the music industry—that is all but ancient history.

GUEST CONTRIBUTOR | SARAH FRANCES FIORELLO is a graduate of Shenandoah Conservatory with a BFA in Music Theatre and a Chicago-based poet, writer, and performer.  Instagram: @writtenbysarahfrances

PHOTO|Julieta Cervantes

Broadway in Chicago
presents
First National Tour
Stereophonic
CIBC Theatre
17 East Adams Street
through February 8, 2026

WEBSITE

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: Birds of North America - A Red Orchid Theatre

The Father-Daughter Emotional Field Guide.
PicksInSix® Review | Guest Contributor | Sarah Frances Fiorello

Nestled snugly in their intimate Old Town storefront performance space, A Red Orchid Theatre is lighting a slow, smoldering fire of generational drama with the Chicago Premiere of “Birds of North America” set to warm the coldest of Chicago winter nights.

John and his daughter, Caitlyn, are birding from John’s backyard in suburban Maryland, while the two travel through a decade of relational touchpoints. Stage lights rise and fall on this father-daughter duo, marking the many seasons of their respective lives as well as demonstrating time’s ability to erode even the most certain of those seasons. John and Caitlyn peer through their binoculars searching for rare birds, while simultaneously searching for the missing connection within their relationship. Like those elusive winged creatures, they never quite seem to find each other, despite their love and obvious devotion. Their profound humanity in continuing to try will have you rooting for them until the final curtain.

What the ensemble of A Red Orchid Theatre manages to produce in what I’d affectionately call a “micro” theatre space is inspiring and invigorating with “Birds of North America” being no exception: there is nowhere to hide from the themes playwright Anna Ouyang Moench asks us to examine. Her writing nearly demands us to think with adequate complexity on “Us vs. Them” political and philosophical arguments, taking big swings at touchy ideologies: privilege of principle-based living and “working to live vs. living to work” chief among them. Her writing is compassionate while necessarily confrontational—pushing on that stubborn wall between our differing views, pulling on our shared humanity to connect in spite of it.

“Birds of North America” is directed by A Red Orchid Theatre Artistic Director Kirsten Fitzgerald and features standout original composition by Composer and Sound Designer Ethan Korvne. The play’s soundscape is contemplative, gentle, and stirring, offering a surprisingly moving touch to the feel of the story with Morgan Laszlo’s rustic scenic design matched by Seojung Jang’s lighting design. On a particularly blustery winter night, I was warmed to the core by this striking, original, powerful new work.

Equity Jeff-Award winner Cassidy Slaughter-Mason offers a composed and contemplative performance as Caitlyn. Deftly portraying the woes and realities of young adult life in the 21st Century, we share her hope against hope that her science-minded father might understand her, as a person first and a statistic second. A Red Orchid Theatre Ensemble Member John Judd expertly unravels the character of John, a committed conservationist and scientist who isn’t entirely wrong in his staunch pragmatism but often fails to see exactly why that matters. There are about as many iterations of father-daughter struggles as there are bird calls in the wild; this piece drills down to the essence of them all, managing to capture something deeply personal while being sweepingly universal and hauntingly specific.

“Birds of North America” is playing now through February 22nd at A Red Orchid Theatre and is worth braving whatever snow and cold may stand between you and their space on Wells St. There is no need to brush up on your North American Field Guide before attending, but you may find yourself wanting to dig it out on your way home. Before bundling up to attend the theatre, leave it on your nightstand as the second special treat of the evening.

CONTENT ADVISORY: This production includes discussion of miscarriage and brief violence.

GUEST CONTRIBUTOR | SARAH FRANCES FIORELLO is a graduate of Shenandoah Conservatory with a BFA in Music Theatre and a Chicago-based poet, writer, and performer. Instagram: @writtenbysarahfrances

PHOTO|Evan Hanover

A Red Orchid Theatre
presents
Chicago Premiere
Birds of North America
1531 North Wells Street
through February 22, 2026

WEBSITE

TICKETS

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

DRAW THE CURTAIN. DIM THE LIGHTS. MEMORABLE PERFORMANCE PICKS FOR 2025

DRAW THE CURTAIN. DIM THE LIGHTS.
Memorable Performance Picks for 2025
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

It is hard to believe that CONVERSATIONS|PicksInSix® turned ten this year. To be honest, with the shutdown, it feels a bit more like the second act of a ten scene play with an overly long intermission. The post-pandemic era in which we live still has mighty challenges for the performing arts, but the new normal has had a spirited rebirth that continues to provide a wide range of offerings to Chicago audiences.

It is always a challenge to single out the memorable moments of the shows we cover each year, including both onstage artists and off stage creative teams. We cannot see everything, but we try to do our best in theaters across the city and suburbs as well as the work of producers who bring their projects for Chicago’s diverse and discerning audiences.

Among the notable productions in that last category that fall outside the year-end review were “Sunny Afternoon,” and “Billy Jean” at Chicago Shakespeare, “Kimberly Akimbo,” “Parade” and “The Sound of Music” at Broadway in Chicago and the touring production of “Les Miserables” that we saw at Broadway in South Bend with Chicago’s own Matt Crowle in the role of Thenardier. Chicago’s Larry Yando is still out making magic on the road with “Harry Potter,” as are the wonderful Heidi Kettenring and Gene Weygandt with “A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical” and a rising star we think you will be hearing a lot more about, Darilyn Burtley, who is touring as Tina Turner in “Tina.” Chicago talent is making an impression everywhere.

There were some disappointments, too, chiefly that “BOOP! The Musical,” with the stunning Jasmine Amy Rogers and Steppenwolf’s “Little Bear Ridge Road,” with the captivating Laurie Metcalf, did not transfer well to New York after sensational runs in town.  

Chicago is a creative laboratory for theatre, despite the challenges facing everyone at a time when our arts and live performance creators are reimagining operating models. It is a big lift to maintain the delicate balance between developing new talent and consistently presenting ambitious, unique and profitable projects. The responsibility for future success does not rest with one faction. It will take the combined efforts of emerging artists, educators, every theatre company and their leadership working with angel donors, sponsors, technical professionals and volunteer organizations like the Jeff Committee to infuse energy, enthusiasm and financial support.

It is a business, however, and all creative artists involved deserve to be respected for their own investment and given the opportunity to earn a living doing what they do so well. One of the most exciting developments evolving now is the three-year, $600,000 grant from the Paul M. Angell Foundation for Theater Wit's Shared Spaces program that allows the organization to offer reduced rates to producing companies. Imagine if other like-minded philanthropists joined to establish a universal live production endowment, perhaps managed independently on a pro-bono basis by a group of investment and industry professionals who distributed funds solely for the benefit and sustainability of performing artistic organizations in Chicago. If you would like to talk about the possibilities, let’s get in touch.

In the meantime, there are dozens of individuals who dedicate their time and talent to the Chicago theatre community. Our regional and national publicists provide invaluable, comprehensive support—at all times of the day and night—and allow the media access to create features, promotional pieces and reviews. It’s an honor to be invited and a responsibility that we all take very seriously. Thank you!

The brilliant Chicago theatre photographers like Michael Brosilow, Brett Beiner, Joe Mazza, Todd Rosenberg, Evan Hanover, Kyle Flubacker, Justin Barbin, Boris Martin and videographers HMS Media, among many others, commit their expertise and professionalism to document these productions and preserve a vivid archive for future generations. A special mention to the late Rich Hein (a/k/a/ Liz Lauren) whose passing this year was a stunning loss. Our gallery tribute was a testament to only a small portion of his work over a decades long photographic career.

This year CONVERSATIONS|PicksInSix® celebrated 10 years creating a fascinating archive of conversations and hundreds of reviews that would have not been possible without the support of writers like Ronald Keaton, Scott Gryder, Kaitlyn Linsner, Sarah Frances Fiorello, Catey Sullivan and Regina Belt-Daniels. Thank you most sincerely. Special thanks to the American Theatre Critics/Journalists Association and Theatre in Chicago’s Mark Meyer for coalescing critical reviews for the public at large.

In the end, it’s all about the show. Our thanks to all of the artists and organizations who invited us to share in their productions. Each performance is a new and exciting experience. What follows, in alphabetical order, are a few of the memorable moments, with a link to the review, from the shows that stood out as among the best and brightest for 2025:

Shanésia Davis – The storyline of the classic “A Raisin in the Sun” at Court Theatre, directed by Senior Artistic Producer Gabrielle Randle-Bent, is largely based on playwright Lorraine Hansberry’s own experiences growing up on the South Side of Chicago. The brilliant company was led by the riveting performance of Shanésia Davis as Lena ‘Mama’ Younger, the matriarch of the family. Simply astounding! P6

Sean Fortunato – Over the years, Sean Fortunato has expertly been reshaping dramatic, comic and musical roles on stages across the city and suburbs. This year, Fortunato shined in Marriott’s “Catch Me If You Can” but it was his inspired take on Dogberry in Chicago Shakespeare’s “Much Ado About Nothing”—which you can still see on stage there—that has elevated his comic abilities to a new level of entertainment. A tour-de-force performance! P6  

David Girolmo – For decades, working actors like David Girolmo go whenever and wherever the job sends them. Thankfully this year, we have had two opportunities to view this fine actor at work. In “Titanic” at Marriott Theatre, Girolmo’s Captain E.J. Smith was dashing, stalwart and vulnerable. Now playing in Paramount’s glorious production of “White Christmas,” Girolmo renders a commanding performance as the beloved General Waverly. A stately and superb craftsman! P6

 “Jeykll & Hyde” – Simply everything about Derek Van Barham’s direction of the Kokandy production at Chopin Theater was fabulous on opening night, from the soaring vocals of David Moreland, Ava Lane Stovall and Emily McCormick, Brenda Didier’s dynamic choreography, the on-stage presence of a 15-piece orchestra, and a multi-talented ensemble under the extraordinary musical direction of Nick Sula. Still playing at Chopin with limited availability. P6

Michelle Lauto – One of our favorite shows of the year, Paramount’s “Waitress,” starred Michelle Lauto as Jenna whose transition in life plays out in a single moment of truth in Lauto’s stunning, soul-searching rendition of “She Used to Be Mine.” A stunner! P6

James Sherman – Ronald Keaton wrote that “First Lady of Television” is “Sherman's marvelous, articulate plunge into show business history,” with William Dick and Cindy Gold playing beautifully together. “This is an ensemble play built on purpose and earnest leanings, as playwright Sherman shows us all, despite the history we think we know, what was still good in that time and place.” P6

A very worthy final bow to: 

Roberts Falls’ directorial debut of “Amadeus” at Steppenwolf and Charles Newell’s “Berlin.” Each one quite simply a masterpiece! … the captivating stage presence of Aurora Penepacker in Kokandy’s “Amélie.” More please! … the depth and experience of Francis Guinan on full display in Goodman’s “Ashland Avenue” … Phoebe Gonzalez’s bravura performance in Writers’ “As You Like It”…  puppet master Jesse Mooney-Bullock’s stunning work on Marriott’s “Nemo” … exceptional scenic designers Collette Pollard (Northlight’s “Gaslight” and Marriott’s “Titanic: The Musical”) and Andrew Boyce (Court Theatre’s “A Raisin in the Sun” and Writer’s “Translations”) and a few world-class stocking stuffers: Liz Callaway:To Steve with Love, the live concert tribute to Stephen Sondheim (as seen and heard at the Studebaker Theater) … Paul Marinaro’s – Mood Ellington and Elaine Dame’s – Reminiscing. You can still order all of them in time for Christmas!

Happy Holidays!

See you on the other side of the aisle!

Ed Tracy is an award-winning television and webcast producer, author, editor and program host. A career nonprofit professional, Tracy is President of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC, a professional management company and is a licensed real estate agent with Cressy & Everett Real Estate in St. Joseph, Michigan. CONVERSATIONS|PicksInSix® reviews theatre in Chicago and throughout the Midwest. American Theatre Critics/Journalists Association

PHOTO Credits: Michael Brosilow, Brett Beiner, Joe Mazza, Todd Rosenberg, Evan Hanover, Kyle Flubacker, Justin Barbin, Boris Martin

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: JEKYLL & HYDE - Kokandy Productions - Chopin Theatre

“Go Where No Angel Will Go.”
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

It’s no surprise that any revival of “JEKYLL & HYDE” requires a blockbuster performer in the challenging dual role of the steadfast Dr. Henry Jekyll and his evil alter ego, Edward Hyde. Director Derek Van Barham has accomplished just that in casting the explosive David Moreland in the Kokandy Productions revival that opened Saturday on the Chopin Theatre Mainstage. Moreland’s dynamic presence, with Ava Lane Stovall as the sultry Lucy and Emily McCormick as Jekyll’s conflicted fiancé Emma, anchor a top flight ensemble of enormous depth and versatility, buoyed by Brenda Didier’s delightfully quirky choreography, Nick Sula’s exceptional music direction and the on-stage presence and staggering brilliance of a 15-piece orchestra.

The story, based on the Robert Louis Stevenson classic novella, examines the medical phenomenon of dual personalities and the research of Jekyll, a highly regarded physician in 1888 London. Jekyll must defend his seven years of research before a skeptical Board of Governors of St. Jude’s Hospital. His proposal is to divide a human subject’s personality in two—one good, the other evil; “compassion and hate”—in an attempt to rid the world of evil. Provoked by Jekyll’s arch nemesis, Simon Stride (Quinn Kelch), the Governors flatly reject the proposal with only Emma’s father Sir Danvers Carew (Nathan Calaranan) abstaining. Incensed and bitter, Jekyll is left to explore other means to test his theory.

At the engagement party at Danvers’ home, Emma confirms her devotion to the troubled Jekyll. Later, along the streets of London, he and his friend and lawyer, Gabriel John Utterson (Kevin Webb), visit The Red Rat, a brothel run by Spider, where Jekyll meets the ravishing Lucy who unsuccessfully plies her charms only to receive an earnest promise of assistance in the future from him. On the way home, Jekyll tells Utterson that his only course forward is to take the potion himself. Despite the consequences, Jekyll proceeds and the catastrophic result is the awakening of the merciless killer Edward Hyde who begins his deadly campaign of retribution.

 “JEKYLL & HYDE” was conceived for the stage by Frank Wildhorn and Steve Cuden with music by Wildwood and book and lyrics by Leslie Bricusse. The challenging piece is in expert hands here with an intriguing gothic aesthetic at work in the creative scenic design of Sotirios Livaditis, a multi-level chamber that serves the movement of the piece well and frames the orchestra upstage. Rachel Sypniewski’s goth influenced costumes provide rich texture against the stark atmospheric lighting design of G “Max” Maxin IV. Matt Reich’s sound work here is simply exceptional.

The show relies on expressive, full featured arrangements and nuanced underscoring that are all expertly interpreted by Sula to provide a rich and unmatched musical foundation. Moreland’s vocal work throughout, and especially on the soaring anthem “This Is The Moment,” is flawless. McCormick delivers a commanding “Take Me As I Am” and “Once Upon A Dream.” Stovall sets the table with the boisterous “Bring On The Men,” her powerful delivery of “Someone Like You,” and then brings the show to a full stop with her exquisite and impassioned “A New Life.”

It doesn’t get better than this!

PHOTO|Evan Hanover

Kokandy Productions
presents
JEKYLL & HYDE
Chopin Theatre
1543 W. Division
through December 21, 2025

WEBSITE

TICKETS

PROGRAM

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: The Sound of Music - Broadway in Chicago

She is gentle! She is wild!
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

“How do you hold a moonbeam in your hand?” That lyric from “Maria” was top of mind going in to the sensational touring production of “The Sound of Music,” directed by Jack O’Brien, now playing at Broadway in Chicago’s James M. Nederlander Theatre. The answer is, of course, you can’t, especially when that shimmering moonbeam is the marvelous Cayleigh Capaldi who portrays Maria, the true-to-life postulant turned governess, wife and survivor, on full display.

Up to this production, I have never fully appreciated the resonance of the Sisters character-defining song “Maria.” It may stem from always being swept away by the intensity of one of the great opening numbers of this, or any, musical of the era that precedes it. Once again I was stunned, lulled and thrust into the iconic Rodgers and Hammerstein score by Capaldi’s rapturous voice beckoning us into the last of the great collaborators eleven Broadway musicals. And then I thought it just might be natural to settle in during “Maria” before looking ahead to the beloved “My Favorite Things” duet that follows it.

Why delve into “Maria” in a musical that delivers so many other iconic works including “Climb Ev’ry Mountain,” “Edelweiss,” “Do-Re-Mi” and “Something Good” all wonderfully performed by this superb company? It’s a beautifully constructed song with every phrase pointing to a nuance of her identity from her singular radiance, exuberance and defiance of norms to her personal magnetism that eventually wins over each of the Sisters and Mother Abbess (played here by the sensational Christiane Noll) by songs’ end.

It’s a tall order to match for an actor, but Capaldi inherently understands Maria, her motivations and the impact that she has on every character in the show, delivering a performance that, like much of the show, is of the moment, fresh, vibrant and overflowing with enthusiasm. In navigating her relationship with Chicago native Kevin Farley’s Captain Georg von Trapp and his children—always the blooming centerpiece of the show and a very endearing group here—Capaldi elevates Maria once again, maturing into her new found purpose as partner and protector.

In every aspect, O’Brien’s production honors the valiant journey of the von Trapp family who escaped oncoming Nazi oppression in 1938 and ultimately delivered them to the mountains of Vermont where the family still maintains a lasting legacy today. The book by Howard Lindsay and Russel Crouse is suggested by Maria’s book The Trapp Family Singers and over the years the elegant Vermont establishment was home. Even a devastating fire that destroyed the main building in 1980, and with it all of Maria’s personal papers and artifacts, did not deter the matriarch of the family to rebuild. Earlier this year, the picturesque 2,600 acre resort celebrated its 75th anniversary, a testament to the lasting legacy of the family at the heart of this beautiful story.

Whether this is the first or fourth viewing for you, “The Sound of Music” at the Nederlander will provide a deep appreciation for the courage, resilience and hope embodied in the von Trapp family and, as well, one of the most satisfying and enjoyable theatrical experiences you will ever have.  

PHOTO|Jeremy Daniel

Broadway in Chicago
presents
The Sound of Music
The James M. Nederlander Theatre
24 W Randolph Street
through November 2, 2025

WEBSITE

TICKETS

OFFICIAL SHOW WEBSITE

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: Disney's Finding Nemo - Marriott Theatre

Get In The Swim Of Things!
PicksInSix® Review | Guest Contributor | Regina Belt-Daniels

“Disney’s Finding Nemo,” the current Marriott Lincolnshire production for their Theatre for Young Audiences series, is a stunning staged musical remake of the 2003 Disney Pixar film with elaborately creative puppetry. The actors are resplendent in dabbled blues, yellows and purple colored onesies as they energetically and believably bring the adorable seafaring characters to life in the best visual display and use of puppets I’ve seen in my two decades of reviewing.

The familiar adventure story begins with Nemo’s mother’s death by a frightening barracuda before he is hatched. Nemo is one of 400 clownfish eggs, and the only survivor. From there, the staged musical quickly enters the evolving tale of Nemo and his overprotective father Marlin. Both face the unknown for someone they love—each other. Nemo dreams of venturing beyond their cozy anemone home into the vast ocean. But he is captured and taken to Sydney, ending up in an aquarium. Determined to bring Nemo home, Marlin pushes past his fears, and embarks on a daring ocean journey, aided by allies Dory, Crush the 150 year-old sea turtle, and the Tank Gang.

Directed and choreographed by the extremely gifted Amber Mak, with flawless musical direction by Ellie Kahn and a live band, the production boasts breathtaking puppetry design by Jesse Mooney-Bullock, costumes by Theresa Ham (wait till you see the jellyfish) and wigs, hair and makeup by Miquel Armstrong. A simple, easily manipulated Great Barrier Reef setting designed by Milo Blue with soothing oceanic lights designed by Brian Easton and sounds by John Johnson complements the talented ensemble on the intimate theater’s in-the-round stage.

And what an ensemble! Avelyn Lena Choi is an innocent and spirited Nemo, whose chemistry with Devon DeSantis‘s overly protective father clownfish, Marlin, is heart tugging. DeSantis’s Marlin is afraid of whales, sharks and leaving his home, but he is very good at delivering dad jokes and rescuing his son. The ever optimistic Dory, who can read, but is extremely forgetful, especially of Nemo‘s name—Elmo, Mosquito, Harpo, Lego, to mention a few misnomers—is wonderfully portrayed by Leah Morrow. Dory provides some of the show’s most hilarious moments and Morrow’s impeccable timing is a non-stop delight.

The ensemble plays an array of fascinating characters each with their own presence and personality. I especially loved Lorenzo Rush Jr. who among others, plays Nigel the pelican swooping in to narrate/move the plot along and entertainingly engage the audience (“Clap your fins if you think…”) I could easily list every single cast member, but other notables include, Andres J. Deleon (Gurgle, Crush, Moonfish), Adelina Marinello (Pearl’s mom, Chum, Peach, Jellyfish, Moonfish, Turtle), Tommy Rivera-Vega (Gil, Moonfish, Jellyfish, Turtle) and Maya Rowe (coral, Tad’s mom, Bloat, Anchor, Moonfish, Jellyfish, Turtle). The ensemble sings many of the most touching songs amplifying the show’s themes of resilience, courage, love and, especially survival, in “Just Keep Swimming.”

The audience was composed of babes in arms to grandparents, all enthralled with this fun filled production. Be sure to plan to stay after the show for a question and answer session with some of the cast members and production team engaging with the kids who not only say the darnedest things but ask them too! Get in the swim of things for Marriott’s production of “Disney’s Finding Nemo.” A magical journey under the sea is awaiting you!

Casting Note: Patrick Michael Tierney will play Marlin at selected performances.

Guest Contributor | REGINA BELT-DANIELS is a retired special education teacher who has acted, directed, and staged managed throughout Illinois and has reviewed theater for numerous publications for over a decade.
PHOTO|Justin Barbin

Marriott Theatre
presents
Disney’s Finding Nemo
‍10 Marriott Drive
Lincolnshire, IL 60069
though January 4, 2026

847-634-0200

WEBSITE

SHOW SENSORY GUIDE

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC